Home eBooks Open Access Journals
Home
Subscribe: Articles RSS Feed Get New Issue Alerts
Browse Archive

Social Anthropology

Anthropologie sociale

ISSN: 0964-0282 (print) • ISSN: 1469-8676 (online) • 4 issues per year

Volume 26 Issue 4

Issue Information

The invention of gender in stand‐up comedy

Transgression and digression

Marianna Keisalo

This paper explores gender in stand‐up comedy based on 20 months of ethnographic research in Finland and recent media discussion involving the booking of performers for a national comedy tour. As the vast majority of stand‐up comedians are men, discussions of gender tend to focus on the anomalousness of female comedians. These debates often rely on essentialist views of women and stand‐up comedy, presenting female comedians as transgressive due to the perceived incompatibilities of women and comedy. However, the situation in the clubs and performances is more complex. I chart this territory by looking at gender in relation to ‘invention’ and ‘convention’ in stand‐up comedy performance. I explore how some of the conventional, established and expected aspects of stand‐up, such as the public use of power and threat of failure, are related to ideas of gender. I then go on to show how comedy enables invention, new and/or unique ideas and forms. This allows comedians to approach and enact gender in more digressive ways: taking indirect, experimental paths and imaginatively shifting between perspectives and positions to subvert and question roles and patterns. As stand‐up becomes more diverse, discussing gender requires a more nuanced approach going beyond a simple binary.

The fitness of persons in the landscape

Isolation, belonging and emergent subjects in rural Ireland

Adam Drazin

The concept of isolation has dogged anthropological studies of rural Ireland. This paper re‐conceptualises isolation through ethnographic work undertaken on the minibuses run by Rural Transport projects in five counties of Ireland. Instead of seeing isolation as an embedded characteristic of Irish landscapes, histories or of the ageing body, the paper describes dynamic, shifting expectations of belonging and community. On the Rural Transport buses, characteristic moments of witnessing ‘figures in the landscape’ during predictable and routinised journeys produce strikingly new negotiations of alterity and sameness among the passengers. The paper argues for the significance of these moments in developing a socialised, inscribed landscape and new senses of generative agency.

The ‘fierce people’ in the context of US foreign politics

A historical anthropology approach to Napoleon Chagnon's interpretation of the Yanomami

Alexandre Coello de la Rosa

This essay aims to rethink the epistemological study of violence among the Yanomami's Venezuelan and Brazilian world. In doing so, I reopen some of the discussions between Marshall Sahlins and Napoleon Chagnon/National Academy of Sciences (NAS) in the context of the much longer debate about ‘innate aggressiveness’ (as virtue or vice) as it came to be revived in the context of the Cold War, decolonisation and the protests against the Vietnam War.

Lives opposed

Perceptivity and tacticality in conflict and crime

Henrik Vigh

This article looks at the way people tactically adjust to contexts of insecurity and danger. Building on fieldwork with disenfranchised urban poor in West Africa and marginal West African migrants in Europe, it clarifies how perspectives and practices are attuned to precarious situations and life conditions. The article argues that the struggle to identify threats leads to a nervous sociality in which figures and social forces are examined for hidden intentions and negative potentials. Such circumstances engender an apprehensive bearing, as an affective state, posture and approach, through which social life is sought, investigated and controlled. It augments perceptivity and leads to a scanning and probing of social life that feeds into a social version of the hermeneutics of suspicion and generates a range of pre‐emptive practices.

Time and politics in the scientific ice age

Ricardo Gomes Moreira

Littlewood, Roland and Rebecca Lynch (eds.) 2016. Cosmos, gods and madmen: frameworks in the anthropologies of medicine. New York: Berghahn Books. 220pp. Hb.: US$120.00/£85.00. ISBN: 978‐1‐78533‐177‐0.

Carolina Ivanescu

Josephides, Lisette and Anne Sigfrid Grønseth (eds.) 2017. The ethics of knowledge creation: transactions, relations, and persons. New York: Berghahn Books. 272 pp. Hb.: US$120.00/£85.00. ISBN: 978‐1‐78533‐404‐7.

Emilia Groupp

Ocejo, Richard E. 2017. Masters of craft: old jobs in the new urban economy. Princeton, NJ/Woodstock: Princeton University Press. 344 pp. Hb.: £19.60. ISBN: 9780691165493.

Siún Carden

Howard, Penny McCall. 2017. Environment, labour and capitalism at sea: ‘working the ground’ in Scotland. Manchester: Manchester University Press. 248 pp. Hb.: £75.00. ISBN: 978‐1‐7849‐9414‐3.

Louise Rebecca Senior

Van Esterik, Penny and Richard O'Connor. 2017. The dance of nurture: negotiating infant feeding. Oxford/New York: Berghahn Books. 248 pp. Hb.: £85.00. ISBN: 978‐1‐78533‐562‐4.

Francesca Vaghi

Reconsidering the Andaman Islands in anthropology and history

Claudia Aufschnaiter

Myhre, Knut Christian (ed.) 2016. Cutting and connecting: ‘Afrinesian’ perspectives on networks, relationality, and exchange. New York/Oxford: Berghahn Books. 162 pp. Pb.: US$27.95/£19.00. ISBN: 9781785332630.

Tyler Zoanni

Shaffner, Justin and Huon Wardle (eds.) 2017. Cosmopolitics: the collected papers of the Open Anthropology Cooperative, volume I. St Andrews: Open Anthropology Cooperative Press. 366, pp. Pb.: US$15.00. ISBN: 9781541348219.

Leif Grünewald

Pountney, Laura and Tomislav Maric. Introducing anthropology: what makes us human? Cambridge: Polity Press. 342 pp. Hb.: US$39.95. ISBN: 9780745699783.

Caesar Perkowski

Brumann, Christopher and David Berliner (eds.) 2016. World Heritage on the ground. New York/Oxford: Berghahn Books. 336 pp. Hb.: US$99.00. ISBN: 9781785330919.

Federica Banfi

Oosterbaan, Martijn. Transmitting the spirit. Religious conversion, media, and urban violence in Brazil. University Park, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press. 256 pp. Hb.: US$84.95. ISBN: 978027107834.

Rosana Carvalho Paiva

Adebanwi, Wale (ed.) 2017. The political economy of everyday life in Africa: beyond the margins. Martlesham: James Currey. 384 pp. Hb.: $74.46. ISBN: 9781847011657.

Rosalie Allain

Chrzan, Janet and John Brett (eds.) 2017. Food culture: anthropology, linguistics, and food studies. Research Methods for Anthropological Studies of Food and Nutrition, vol. II. New York: Berghahn Books. 275 pp. Hb: US$130.00/£92.00. ISBN: 9781785332890.

Madeline Chera

Mostowlansky, Till. 2017. Azan on the moon. Entangling modernity along Tajikistan's Pamir Highway. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press. 216 pp. Pb.: US$26.95. ISBN: 9780822964438.

Galen Murton

Parry, Bronwyn, Beth Greenhough, Tim Brown and Isabel Dyck (eds.) 2015. Bodies across borders: the global circulation of body parts, medical tourists and professionals. Farnham/Burlington, VT: Ashgate Publishing. 230 pp. Hb.: £65.00. ISBN: 9781409457176.

Eva‐Maria Knoll

El Shakry, Omnia. 2017. The Arabic Freud: psychoanalysis and Islam in modern Egypt. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. 244 pp. Hb.: US$35.00. ISBN: 9780691174792.

Emilia Groupp

Beck, Kurt, Gabriel Klaeger and Michael Stasik (eds.) 2017. The making of the African road. Leiden/Boston, MA: Brill. 290 pp. Eb.: US$69.00. E‐ISBN: 9789004339040.

Florin Faje

The reciprocity of perspectives

Roy Wagner

As a tactic of cognitive self‐awareness, the reciprocity of perspectives is not so much a subjective metric for intercultural comparison as it is an internalised property of human sentience, which I label as a subject/object shift: the transposition of ends and means. Understood most broadly as a universal application of the double proportional comparison, made famous by Claude Lévi‐Strauss as the canonical formula for myth, the reciprocity of perspectives, instead of opposing the innate and the artificial (e.g. ‘nature’ and ‘culture’) to one another, presupposes a reciprocal, self‐contradiction between the two. I examine the self‐transformative and tactical character of the reciprocity of perspectives and its effects on language itself, which ceases to be an instrument of communication and takes on the role of communicator or persuader – that of the user rather than the tool.

Alpes, Maybritt Jill. 2017. Brokering high‐risk migration and illegality in West Africa. Abroad at any cost. London/New York: Routledge. 234 pp. Hb.: £110. ISBN: 9781472441119.

Jesper Bjarnesen

Hart, Keith (ed.) 2017. Money in a human economy. Oxford/New York: Berghahn Books. 314 pp. Hb.: US$120.00. ISBN: 9781785335594.

Mariano Perelman

Evens, Terry, Don Handelman and Christopher Roberts (eds.) 2016. Reflecting on reflexivity: the human condition as an ontological surprise. New York: Berghahn. xiv + 309 pp. Hb.: US$140.00/£100.00. ISBN: 978‐78238‐751‐0.

Eyal Ben‐Ari

Tactics of association

Theodoros Kyriakides

This essay puts Michel de Certeau's work on tactics in conversation with the work of F. G. Bailey on tactical subjects and Roy Wagner's work on alliance. In doing so, my objective is to introduce the notion of the association as an essential aspect of a contemporary anthropological theory of tactics. I approach the notion of association from three angles: as an ethnographic object and political entity, as an anthropological analytical tool and as a pragmatic, political gesture. By analysing associations from these three interrelated perspectives, I attempt to shift attention away from understandings of tactics as having to do with spontaneous creativity, cunning and reversal of power. Instead, I showcase that the deployment of tactics demands the setting up and maintenance of a tactical infrastructure of alliance, capable of making the future and pre‐emptive deployment of tactics possible.

MacClancy, Jeremy (ed.) 2017. Anthropology and public service. The UK experience. Oxford/New York: Berghahn. 202 pp. Hb.: US$95.00/£67.00. ISBN: 9781785334023.

Lisa Marie Borrelli

A celebration of Roy Wagner and ‘The reciprocity of perspectives’

Sarah GreenMarilyn StrathernIracema DulleyMartin HolbraadAlberto Corsín JiménezMarianna KeisaloFrederick H. Damon

Editorial

Sarah GreenPatrick Laviolette

Methodologically blonde at the UN in a tactical quest for inclusion

Miia Halme‐Tuomisaari

How can anthropologists negotiate access in high‐profile, bureaucratic apparatuses, such as a UN human rights monitoring mechanism – and what can a detailed account of these negotiations tell us of such apparatuses, their operational dynamics and the processes through which they exert an impact, broadly construed? This article addresses these questions through the notion of tactical subjectivity by anchoring its discussion on the category of the intern and detailing how this category became informative of the ‘fuzzy logic’ of the UN apparatus. The article outlines three techniques mobilised in the process – name‐dropping, ‘playing blonde’ and opportunism – all embedded in a tactical matrix of exaggerated transparency. The article further shares attempts to flesh out relations and thus form ‘liaisons’ between my interlocutors and myself at sessions of the UN Human Rights Committee, the most influential of all the UN treaty bodies overseeing how states comply with their covenant‐bound obligations. The ultimate aim was to become a conspicuous ethnographer with constant access – a volatile goal in the unpredictable microstructures of this awesome global apparatus.

Tactics as ethnographic and conceptual objects

Introduction to special section

Theodoros Kyriakides

This special section proposes that an ethnographic and conceptual emphasis on tactics can contribute to anthropological understandings of thinking, acting and being in the world. Although they can be perceived as intrinsic tenets of human sociality and subjectivity, tactical thinking and doing are becoming important parts of socio‐political landscapes around the world. Approaching the notion of tactics ethnographically demands highlighting how and why tactical sociality and subjectivity emerge in everyday life. Granting ethnographic attention to tactical practices of people can aid in showcasing how such practices do not merely strive to fulfil a certain outcome, but rather attempt to reinforce awareness of one's, often uncertain, structural position in a social, political or legal apparatus. In addition, a conceptual emphasis on tactics can provide a useful analytic lens in rethinking notions of relationality, agency, structure and method as these are contained in already existing anthropological concepts, such as habitus, access, alliance, subjectivity and uncertainty. By ethnographically and conceptually exploring tactical sociality and subjectivity as they become implicated in everyday contexts and situations, the articles in this section aim to provide a contemporary anthropological perspective of tactics.